Would You Pay for Home Value Insurance?

Home value insurance is a little idea that economists like to throw around which proposes that home owners should have the option to purchase insurance on the value of their home. This would protect the value of your home should, for instance, a few neighbors stop caring for their property, a factory is built nearby, or the nearest school’s funding is cut. These are all issues that could decrease the value of your home, but are, for the most part, out of your control.

Zoning restrictions are in place to ensure that an incompatible use doesn’t move in that vacant lot next door. No one wants a rubber factory in their backyard–not only are there negative health effects, but the value of your home could plummet. However, zoning is not a fail-safe, and sometimes owners suddenly find themselves in a neighborhood that appears to be falling apart. The best way to combat unwanted changes in your neighborhood is to become involved in the community, attend community meetings and zoning hearings, and let your concerns be heard by the people making decisions about new developments.

An issue with home value insurance is that it poses a moral hazard. This means that, once someone has insurance on the value of their home, they might not be so inclined to become involved in neighborhood or community issues. If they have protected themselves against a decrease in the value of their home, what is the incentive to protest unwanted development nearby?

Another issue is that home values are driven by many various factors. Home value insurance could only be effective if the baseline value of the home were established, and then tracked very closely by an appraiser. Even then, it would be difficult to determine the source of the decline (or increase, for that matter) in home value, not to mention the cost of paying an appraiser to track all the insured homes.

Still, home value insurance remains an interesting idea, though not many places have offered it, to date.

Would you be interested, if home value insurance were offered to you?


Real Property Management is the nation’s leading property manager. For over 30 years, Real Property Management has developed intelligent solutions for thousands of individual property owners, investors, tenants and Realtors. What can Real Property Management do for you?

Follow us on Instagram! RPM_Midwest



0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.